In Depth Lens Tests: Leica Summicron-C vs Leica Summilux-C
- January 13, 2016
- Shane Hurlbut, ASC
Today we are comparing Leica Summicron-C lenses to Leica Summilux-C lenses. We will be looking at similarities and differences between the lenses. It’s important to compare lenses so you can really find how each lens reads your talent.
Leica Summicron-C 21/75mm VS Leica Summilux-C 21/75mm
Here are the specs:
Here we have an ungraded image of our model Monette taken with the 21mm Summicron.
Below we have our 21mm Summilux result.
If you look at the two results side by side, the Summilux is warmer and has more yellow than the Summicron. The Summicron is a much whiter lens.
Another thing to note is that the background of the Summilux is brought to the foreground and has a flatness to it. It loses that three dimensional quality, but is sharper than the Summicron. The difference is subtle, but if you look at her face, you can see the Summilux has more sharpness than the Summicron. The curb in the background also looks closer to her with the Summilux.
The background looks pretty similar with both lenses. The flatness is there, and the background with the Summilux still seems closer to the foreground. When looking at contrast, the Summicron seems to have a little more contrast than the Summilux. The Summicron is more saturated, so that’s why it has more contrast.
With the Summilux, notice the yellow of the lens.
In the side by side comparison, it is really apparent that the Summilux lens has a lot more yellow than the Summicron.
Here is the graded version so we can see the contrast better.
The 75mm Summilux looks less yellow than the 21mm Summilux, but both Summilux lenses still look more yellow than the Summicrons. With the side by side comparison below, what I’m seeing just in the 75mm is that the Summilux is flatter. Looking at her face, her face is flatter with the 75mm Summilux than it is with the 75mm Summicron.
The Summicron felt creamier. It wasn’t so hyper sharp. We knew we were dealing with a fast shooting tv show, and we were shooting in New Orleans where it’s humid. People would be sweating, and the makeup on the talent would be affected by this, so we wanted to use creamier, less hyper sharp lenses.
When shooting with the Summicron lenses, I felt like I was shooting with Panavision Primo lenses. The qualities I love with the Panavision Primos, I saw with the Summicron lenses both onscreen and while shooting with them. There was detail, creaminess, but still a sharpness.
Taking the Lenses to the Backyard
Now we’re set up in the backyard. Monette is backlit, and there are flowers in the background, so we can look at the contrast and color with the lenses. Here are ungraded images with the 75mm Summicron lens and the 75mm Summilux lens.
Again, the Summicrons seem more neutral and white, and the Summilux looks more yellow. Monette’s face has more yellow with the Summilux.
Now let’s look at our graded version.
With the Summilux, you can immediately see a sharpness. She’s definitely sharper on her face, and if you look underneath her chin, you can see much more detail and definition with the Summilux. The Summilux is a sharper piece of glass, and the Summicron tends to cream out her face and there is less detail with that lens.
At the Corral, a Less Controlled Environment
Next, we took the Summicron and Summilux lenses into the corral, where we have a lot of white warmish bounce coming off of the ground. Starting with our 21mm lenses, we have our Summicron and Summilux 21mm ungraded images.
Looking at the background, I see a little size difference with the lenses. With the Summilux, the background seems closer and the image is flatter. The Summilux brings the fence line and all the trees closer. It’s a subtle difference because both lenses are engineered with computers to be as flat as possible.
Moving onto the graded versions:
Looking at the side by side, the Summilux still looks more yellow. The flatness looks about the same, but the Summilux makes her look younger than the Summicron. You can really see how much younger she looks with the Summilux with the 75mm lens comparison.
Notice that with the Summicron, Monette’s wrinkles look a slight bit more pronounced, making her look older than she looks with the Summilux.
Looking at the side by side comparison, you really can see that she looks younger with the Summilux lens.
You can also see this with the graded version of the 75mm lens comparison.
With the Summilux, her face looks more filled out, making her look younger than she looks with the Summicron 75mm. The Summicron makes her look more sophisticated. It’s strange, but these are the kind of things you look for when you’re comparing lens tests. To sum up these lenses:
● Makes Monette look a bit older when compared to how she looks with the Leica Summilux lens
● Is a whiter lens
● Creamier, not as hyper sharp as the Summilux
● More saturated, more contrast
● Slightly more three dimensional
● Makes Monette look younger when compared to how she looks with the Leica Summicron lens
● Is a yellower lens
● Sharper than the Summicron
● A little less saturated, less contrast
● Flatter, slightly less three dimensional